Rating: 2.5 out of 5.

A Christmas Carol is the most well known of any Christmas story. One that has been adapted countless times to varying degrees of success. The most notable and considered the best, is The Muppets Christmas Carol, but you also had Jim Carrey and Robert Zemeckis’ animated version in 2009, as well as the likes as variations of the story, with the likes of Scrooged, Spirited and Christmas Karma. It’s a story many people know so when people come to an adaptation of the story, they need to do something unique and fresh that truly makes this version feel worth while telling. When they hire a director who primarily has experience in the horror genre, I get excited that this could be something fresh, in a story that has a couple of elements of horror already in it. Once marketing started, it was clear this wasn’t the angle it was going for and was going to be more of a family friendly adaptation.

If you don’t know, Ebenezer is the story of Ebenezer Scrooge, a horrible man who dispises christmas and everything associated with it. After his business partner dies, he is visited by his ghosts who informs that he will be visited by 3 more ghosts that will take him on a journey through time in order to teach him a lesson.

When it was announced that Ti West was going to be directing an adaption of A Christmas Carol, it peaked my interest. West is primarily known for his X trilogy (X, Pearl, Maxxxine), a very dark trilogy of films, that are all horror films, and gained a bit of a cult following, so it certainly felt like this adaptation was going to also be more horror focused, and that’s where the uniqueness of this film would come from, and in my head it made sense as a way Johnny Depp could be going back to his routes, after his first role ever was in A Nightmare on Elm Street. And the horror elements of this version are ultimately where this film is at it’s best. Unfortunately, those are just brief moments. I ultimately do think it would’ve been a more interesting and unique film had it chosen that avenue to go down, rather than what we get are little changes, but nothing that makes it feel fresh. Leaving me asking the question, what was the point?

Johnny Depp is obviously a big draw for certain audiences members. This being the biggest film he’s done in about 8 years, since Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald, and his life has certainly had a lot of changes since then. Compared to some of his performances, it is one that can is slightly more subtle (at times) but then sometimes feels like he was trying to do an impression of other versions we’ve seen rather than bringing anything new. It felt very safe. I think he could’ve swung more and been more like what we typically have seen from Depp previously. No doubt he will be more Depp like in The Day Drinker, where it seems he can’t decide if the character is irish or cockney. Scrooge is a character Depp suits ironically, and fits the typical over the top acting that he often does.

The supporting cast do a mixed job. I think Andrea Risborough as the Ghost of Christmas Past, does perhaps the best and most effective job. The most memorable and terrifying look of any ghost in the film. And I think that adds to one of the strengths of the film, is that it has some solid costume design, and make-up. An impactful character that I felt steals the scenes she is in. Tramell Tillman also does a good job as the ghost of christmas present, and Sam Claflin as Ebenezer’s nephew. Someone like Daisy Ridley, a biggish name who has been a lead of a pretty big franchise you might have heard of (Star Wars obviously), has maybe a minute of screentime and yet is the 6th person listed in the credits. Were some of her scenes cut out? What is there isn’t much. Rupert Grint plays Ebenezer’s clerk, Bob Cratchit, and I still feel like he is the only one of the Harry Potter actors who hasn’t been able to find his footing in his career beyong that even 15 years on. In a film with some big names in, he doesn’t stand out and feels clunky at times. Perhaps that’s why he’s returning to play Ron on Broadway.

Overall, I left Ebenezer feeling like it could’ve been so much more if decided to take any sort of swing. The film has a lot of marketing that uses the tagline “Before he was Scrooge he was…” and I don’t feel like you can justify that when it brings such little impact to what they add to the story. The cast do a mixed job, with particularly the cast involved in the horror elements doing the best job. Ebenezer ultimately feels like it will be forgotten about in the list on not just christmas films, but adaptations of this classic story.

Rating: 2.5 out of 5.

What did you think of Ebenezer?

For more reviews be sure to follow @floodersfilms or via the buttons below.

Leave a Reply

Trending